Very Positive(90%)
emotional story
phenomenal soundtrack
charming characters
improved combat
unique storytelling
slow pacing
dated graphics
monotonous combat
fetch quests
PC port issues
repetitive quests
tedious requirements
poor optimization
minimal changes
grindy gameplay
The general sentiment towards NieR Replicant is that it offers a beautiful and emotionally compelling story with excellent character development and a haunting soundtrack. However, many players find themselves frustrated by the repetitive and tedious gameplay mechanics, technical issues with the PC port, and the requirement to replay content multiple times to fully experience the game's narrative. The game touches deeply on existential and philosophical themes, making it a rewarding experience for those willing to look past its flaws.
Positive Points
The game's story is deeply emotional, beautifully told, and filled with unique storytelling elements that make it memorable and impactful.The soundtrack is phenomenal, with ethereal and melancholic tracks that enhance the emotional depth of the game.The characters, especially Kaine, Emil, and Grimoire Weiss, are well-written, charming, and leave a lasting impression on players.NieR Replicant features improved combat mechanics over its original version, with smooth and satisfying gameplay.The game delivers a unique world-building experience filled with profound and thought-provoking themes.Negative Points
The game suffers from repetitive tasks and fetch quests, which can make the experience feel tedious and time-consuming.Players are required to replay significant portions of the game multiple times to achieve all endings, which can feel like a chore due to minimal changes in subsequent playthroughs.There are issues with the PC port, such as poor optimization, frame rate caps, and some technical bugs requiring mods to fix.The side quests are often seen as lacking in value or creativity, adding little to the story or gameplay.Mixed Points
While some players appreciate the game's narrative and character development, others find the slow pacing and repetitive nature to be a significant drawback.The art and graphics of the game are praised for their style but are also criticized by some for feeling outdated by modern standards.Combat is seen as fluid and engaging by some players, while others describe it as lacking depth and becoming monotonous over time.Common Themes
There is a strong appreciation for the game's storytelling, emotional depth, and character development across reviews.The soundtrack consistently receives high praise for its quality and impact on the game's atmosphere.Many players mention the grindy nature of the game, especially the repetitiveness required to achieve multiple endings.Technical issues with the PC port are frequently noted, impacting the overall experience for some players.Updated 8/9/2025, 12:01:43 AM UTC