Overall, the reviews of No Man's Sky reflect a redemption arc from a troubled launch to a beloved exploration game with continuous updates. Many players appreciate the vast and seamless universe, highlighting both the game's technical prowess and its engaging content. However, criticisms arise regarding repetitive gameplay and technical issues, with some finding certain mechanics shallow or underwhelming despite the expansive content. The game's narrative and approach to multiplayer also elicit varied responses, but the general sentiment is one of forgiveness and admiration for how the developers have consistently improved and grown the game over the years.

Overall, the sentiment towards the game is largely positive with significant appreciation for its art style and combat mechanics. However, there are notable criticisms, particularly regarding performance issues and the grindiness of certain game mechanics, which are seen as detracting from the experience. The storyline and build system receive mixed reviews, and while some players enjoy these aspects, others express frustration. The multiplayer feature is appreciated, though it is marred by the friendly fire mechanic.

The general sentiment of the reviews highlights a successful homage to the original Gothic game, praised for its authentic atmosphere, visual fidelity, and respect for classic RPG elements. However, it is also marred by performance issues and a frustrating lockpicking system, leading to a range of experiences among players. Despite some controversy over combat mechanics and adaptations for modern gamers, the remake is appreciated for reviving a beloved classic with enthusiasm from passionate fans, while also facing critical challenges in technical execution.

The game is praised for its deep customization and vast array of build options, as well as its graphics and animations which create a visually stunning experience. However, players commonly report performance issues like lag and stuttering. There is significant frustration with the patching system that can cause downtime, and expensive microtransactions have also been criticized. While the complexity and steep learning curve are mixed points, they reflect the game's depth. Finally, comparisons to Diablo highlight its superior challenge and content.