The general sentiment around Warhammer 40,000: Darktide is one of focus on compelling co-op gameplay within an immersive Warhammer 40k setting. Players express enthusiasm for the game's rich atmosphere, satisfying combat mechanics, and diverse class options. However, there is also significant criticism regarding the game's performance issues, server stability, and predatory microtransactions. While some players find joy in the game's chaotic melee and gunplay, others are deterred by the repetition and technical problems.

The general sentiment among players is a mix of nostalgia-fueled appreciation and frustration. While many cherish the nostalgic memories and unique classes, they express concern about the game's monetization, technical issues, and reliance on grinding for progression. Players fondly recall the game's visuals and music but are often disheartened by its current state, especially the pay-to-win elements and frequent bugs.

Overall, the sentiment towards the game is filled with nostalgia and appreciation for the beautiful recreation of Sodor, bringing joy to long-time fans. However, the bugs, pricing strategy concerning DLC, and lack of features such as cutscene skipping and dynamic free roam mode lead to mixed feelings among players. Many see potential in the game if these issues are addressed and if future updates bring improvements and more content.

The general sentiment among reviewers is a mixture of enthusiasm for the game's realism and tactical gameplay, coupled with frustration over AI issues and the pricing model. The game's difficulty is polarizing, appreciated by some for the challenge while others find it overwhelming. Despite perceived graphical downgrades and content changes following its console release, the game is still recommended by many as a leading tactical shooter, particularly when played together with friends, although there is significant discontent surrounding the Paid DLCs and ongoing AI problems.