Most reviewers consider this a standout Resident Evil entry, especially praising Grace’s tense survival-horror sections, Leon’s satisfying action combat, and the atmosphere and presentation. The central switch between two very different playstyles works brilliantly for many but feels disjointed to others, and players disagree about how well the story and nostalgia callbacks land. Common criticisms include the short campaign and weaker later sections, uneven storytelling and pacing, and, for some PC players, restricted camera options or technical issues.

The reviews are strongly positive overall, with players especially drawn to Night City's atmosphere, memorable characters, and emotional storytelling, as well as flexible builds and replayable content. Many say the game has become a standout experience after major updates, and Phantom Liberty earns particular enthusiasm. However, crashes, bugs, and uneven performance still affect some players, while dialogue-heavy pacing, repetitive activities, and limited consequences for some choices divide opinion.

Overall, reactions are divided. Fans and co-op partners often enjoy creative teamwork and new puzzle mechanics, as well as the visuals and music. However, many report broken or unreliable voice chat, bugs that interrupt or block progress, and unclear or repetitive puzzles. The gravity-shifting sequences and departure from the earlier games’ atmosphere and puzzle style are especially divisive, leaving some players delighted while others see a disappointing step down.

Overall sentiment is strongly divided but leans positive among players who enjoy sprawling sandbox RPGs. Reviewers most often celebrate the vast, beautiful world and rewarding exploration, the abundance of activities and flexible play, and often the expressive combat. The main reservations are weak or confusing storytelling and forgettable characters, repetitive quests and unintuitive puzzles, and clunky controls or technical problems. The game’s scale, combat, puzzles, and performance are highly dependent on player preference and hardware, making it a better fit for patient explorers than for players seeking a streamlined, story-focused experience.