The reviews reflect a dynamic relationship with the game. While core gameplay elements and hero shooter mechanics receive praise for their depth and variety, there is strong dissatisfaction with matchmaking and perceived predatory monetization models. The community's toxic behavior and server issues are also frequent points of criticism. Several players feel nostalgic for the game's earlier days and express frustration with unfulfilled promises from the developers. The game inspires a love-hate sentiment for many players, drawing them back despite noted faults.

Game improvements since its initial release have resulted in a much more engaging and immersive experience for players. Reviews largely praise the story, world-building, and visuals of Cyberpunk 2077. However, some bugs and glitches persist, and there's mixed feedback on aspects like the combat difficulty and the impact of player choices on the story. Overall, the game is seen as a significant success and a redemption story in the gaming community.

The game is recognized for its unique and appealing art style, with an atmosphere that nails the 1930s cartoon vibe. Voice acting and character animations are widely praised, especially Troy Baker's performance. However, players criticized the lack of replayability and certain elements that could feel repetitive over time including enemy variety and the indulgence in cheese-based humor. While there are some bugs reported, the strong atmosphere, story, and overall style help create a fun, engaging experience that many consider worth the price.

The game is often considered a masterpiece despite some clunky mechanics and rushed segments. Most players praise its world design and challenging combat as defining strengths, while acknowledging the difficulty as both an engaging challenge and a potential source of frustration. Overall, it remains highly recommended for its unique blend of difficulty, atmosphere, and storytelling in the gaming landscape.