The general sentiment among reviewers is highly positive, with praise directed towards combat, art direction, and the story's unique twist on Pinocchio. However, some criticisms are aimed at linear level design and DLC difficulty, highlighting a mix of reactions primarily hinging on the game's difficulty.

The general sentiment about the game is largely positive towards the graphics and the Warhammer 40K experience, with many praising the engrossing combat and cooperative multiplayer. However, there are notable criticisms regarding technical performance and connectivity issues, which hinder the gameplay. The combat system and reward mechanics receive varied feedback, depending on player preferences for complexity and challenge. Overall, it provides a thrilling ride in the Warhammer 40K universe for fans, but requires improvements in optimization and progression balance adjustments for better overall satisfaction.

Overall, the reviews highlight a detailed and engaging stealth game with massive replayability, thanks to its beautiful maps and diverse gameplay mechanics. However, the confusing pricing and DLC model and online connection requirement are significant drawbacks for many players. While the game excels in offering a variety of playstyles and a visually immersive experience, technical issues and customer satisfaction regarding monetization impact the otherwise largely positive sentiment. The game's commitment to providing freedom of approach is highly valued, but it seems to be at odds with elements that hinder smooth accessibility.

The overall sentiment towards Dead Island 2 is mixed. Players praise the game for its excellent graphics and satisfying combat mechanics, with the gore and physics being particular highlights that enhance the zombie-slaying experience. Despite these strengths, there are significant criticisms of the game, such as technical issues like crashing and problems with online services through Epic Games. The story and dialogue receive heavy criticism for being unoriginal and at times cringeworthy, with an abrupt and unfulfilling ending. The repetitive nature of the gameplay and incessant zombie respawning contribute to player frustration. Despite these criticisms, many players find the game fun, especially when played in co-op, which is noted to scale up the entertainment and gameplay experience.