Overall, sentiment is strongly positive among players who enjoy huge sandbox adventures, with frequent praise for vast, detailed world and rewarding exploration, freedom and sheer variety of activities, and deep, satisfying combat once mastered. The most common reservations are clunky, complicated controls, weak or confusing story and quests, and crashes and performance problems after updates. The game's massive scope and steep learning curve can be either its greatest appeal or a tiring time sink, depending on the player.

Overall sentiment is favorable toward the game itself: players often enjoy satisfying gunplay and flexible build crafting, abundant content and co-op, and a detailed Washington, D.C. world. However, enthusiasm is tempered by disconnects, crashes, and audio bugs, as well as Ubisoft Connect and always-online requirements. The lengthy progression is addictive for loot-focused players but repetitive and confusing for others, and many recommend buying at a discount.

Overall, players find an unusual, often absorbing incremental simulator built around the satisfying potato-peeling loop and distinctive atmosphere. The story and progression add character, though automation changes the gameplay substantially and opinions vary on whether that shift is rewarding or tedious. The most consistent concerns are the short campaign, limited replay options, and late-game handling bugs.

Reviews are strongly drawn to the cozy atmosphere and nostalgic game-restoration loop, with many finding the tactile cleaning, soundtrack, and collection features absorbing and relaxing. However, awkward tool controls, difficult crevices, bugs, and wrist strain undermine the experience for some, especially at launch. Overall, players are divided on the deliberate cleaning pace and limited scope: enthusiasts enjoy the meticulous repetition, while others want smoother mechanics and more variety.