Very Positive(89%)
immersive experience
beautiful visuals
open-world exploration
excellent sound
PVP elements
cooperative play
updates
unpredictable nature
toxic community
repetitive gameplay
server issues
Xbox account
Many reviews indicate that Sea of Thieves is a fun and immersive pirate adventure when played with friends, offering beautiful visuals and engaging naval combat. However, toxic player interactions and a repetitive gameplay loop are common criticisms. While the community emphasizes that the game shines with cooperative play, its PVP elements can often detract from the experience for those seeking a more relaxed adventure.
Positive Points
The game is highly immersive, especially when playing with friends, providing a genuine pirate experience that's both adventurous and engaging.Graphics are praised, with beautiful visuals and realistic water physics enhancing the gameplay experience.Open-world exploration and the ability to create unique pirate stories and adventures are significant highlights.The game's sound design, including music and ambient sound, is considered excellent and adds to the immersion.Negative Points
The community is often criticized as toxic, with frequent griefers and gankers making solo play challenging and sometimes unenjoyable.There are complaints about the game's repetitive gameplay loop and lack of meaningful progression, as cosmetic rewards offer little incentive for some players.The game is plagued with bugs and server issues, with frequent disconnects causing players to lose progress and experience frustration.The necessity for an Xbox account and associated login issues are a source of annoyance for many players.Mixed Points
PVP elements are a point of contention; some players love the unpredictability and tension it brings, while others find it frustrating or unfair.Some updates and additional content are welcome, but they can contribute to a sense of bloat and do not address longstanding issues.Common Themes
The cooperative play with friends significantly enhances the experience, making it feel like a shared adventure.The game's aesthetic and thematic elements, like the pirate setting and oceanic exploration, are well-regarded.Many players enjoy the game's chaotic and unpredictable nature, which can lead to memorable and funny moments.There is a divide between those who appreciate the PVP aspect and those who wish for a more purely PVE experience.Updated 9/26/2025, 12:01:22 AM UTC