The unique art style and blend of gameplay mechanics in Cult of the Lamb receive a lot of praise, with players finding the juxtaposition of cute visuals and dark themes both charming and engaging. Many appreciate the fun and addictive loop provided by the combination of base management and roguelike combat, though some express concerns about repetitiveness and shallow mechanics. The game's soundtrack is a particular highlight, adding to the immersive atmosphere. However, players also note technical issues and a few design choices, like lengthy unskippable animations, as detracting from the experience.