Mostly Positive(74%)
free-to-play model
visuals
card crafting
initial gems
crafting system
free gems
grind
meta reliance
long turns
unbalanced meta
expensive decks
The reviews show a strong initial appreciation for the game's free-to-play accessibility and visual presentation, making it appealing especially to fans of the original Yu-Gi-Oh card game. However, there is significant frustration with the meta-reliant gameplay and lack of balance which creates a stale and unwelcoming environment for casual or new players. Despite the inventive crafting system, the difficulty in maintaining or building multiple decks without monetary investment is problematic. Overall, while it's a visual and nostalgic treat, the game's balance issues with meta decks diminish its appeal.
Positive Points
The game is highly praised for its accessibility as a free-to-play Yu-Gi-Oh simulator that closely resembles the traditional trading card game, making it cost-effective compared to physical cards.Visually, the game is detailed and attractive, featuring sharp graphics, impressive animations, and a great soundtrack that enhances the playing experience.For new players, the initial burst of free gems allows crafting a competitive deck without spending money.The crafting system is highlighted as a major advantage, allowing players to dismantle unwanted cards to create desired ones.Negative Points
Many reviewers criticize the game for its heavy reliance on meta decks for success, leading to repetitive gameplay experiences.There is significant frustration about the long first turns, with players often having to wait for their opponents to complete complex combos before having a chance to play.The current meta, particularly revolving around Maliss and other strong archetypes, is described as unbalanced, creating a stale and uninviting environment.Negative feedback often focuses on the costly and challenging gem system, which discourages casual and experimental gameplay due to the expensive deck-building requirements.Mixed Points
The game's free-to-play model is both praised for its generosity and criticized for feeling like a grind after the initial freebies are exhausted.While the crafting system is seen as a positive feature, obtaining the resources needed to craft competitive decks is viewed as a significant challenge without spending money.Common Themes
Many reviewers express nostalgia for Yu-Gi-Oh and see Master Duel as a way to reconnect with their childhood games.Frustration with the dominance of meta decks and lengthy combo-based strategies that reduce variety and interactivity in gameplay.There is a call for more diverse formats and updates to keep the game fresh and reduce the power creep impact.Updated 9/13/2025, 12:01:53 AM UTC