Overall, the general sentiment towards Wartales is quite positive, with many players praising its immersive mechanics, extensive content, and engaging combat system. However, there are notable issues with bugs and stability, particularly in multiplayer mode. Players appreciate the freedom and open-world aspect, although some feel that narrative depth could be improved. Despite the repetitiveness and DLC criticisms, Wartales is still seen as a strong contender in the tactical RPG genre.
Positive Points
The game is highly praised for its immersive gameplay and mechanics, with players finding it to be one of the best indie CRPGs available.Wartales offers a lot of content and replayability, with players enjoying building their mercenary band, exploring a vast world, and engaging in tactical battles.The game's strategic, turn-based combat system is well-received, likened to classics like Battle Brothers and XCOM.Players appreciate the game's open world, the freedom to create their own stories, and the ability to play as different types of characters such as mercenaries, pirates, or traders.The crafting, resource management, and survival elements add depth to the gameplay experience.Negative Points
Many users report issues with bugs and performance, citing crashes, memory leaks, and stuttering that have persisted over time.Co-op and multiplayer modes are particularly criticized for being buggy, resulting in frequent black screens and connection issues.Some players find the game becomes repetitive over time, with battles feeling tedious due to a lack of variety in combat scenarios and quest objectives.There's criticism over the game's DLC pricing and model, with players feeling that the content should have been part of the base game.Mixed Points
The visual and auditory aspects of the game receive mixed reviews, with some praising its medieval aesthetic while others find the graphics and sounds to be lacking or repetitive.While the game offers an open world with many choices, some players feel that the narrative and story elements need more depth and impact.Common Themes
Players frequently compare the game to titles like Battle Brothers, Mount & Blade, and XCOM, noting similarities in tactical combat and open-world exploration.The challenge balance in Wartales is a common discussion point, with varying opinions on whether the grind and difficulty spikes enhance or detract from the gameplay experience.A significant number of players express a love for the freedom and emergent storytelling in Wartales, despite technical issues.Updated 4/30/2025, 8:41:25 PM UTC
