The general sentiment about Lies of P is overwhelmingly positive from those familiar with the souls-like genre. Many players praise the game's polish and storytelling, highlighting it as a standout entry outside of FromSoftware's typical offerings. There are mixed reactions about the game's difficulty and its linear level design, which some veteran players appreciate while others see as a limitation compared to more explored worlds. However, performance issues on specific hardware have been noted, affecting the experience for some. Overall, the game is well-regarded for its unique twists on traditional mechanics, its engaging narrative, and its auditory experience.