Very Positive(93%)
Weapon customization
Gothic atmosphere
Soundtrack
Pinocchio story
Quality-of-life
Parry-focused combat
Boss difficulty
Linear exploration
Overture DLC
Weapon variety
Tight parries
Difficulty spikes
Ambush placement
Technical stuttering
Reviews are overwhelmingly enthusiastic, with many players calling Lies of P a standout Soulslike for its weapon customization and precise combat, gothic atmosphere and soundtrack, and dark, engaging Pinocchio story. The main reservations are strict parry timing and uneven difficulty spikes, alongside linear exploration and occasional repetition; the DLC is widely praised but can be especially punishing.
Positive Points
Many reviewers consider it one of the strongest non-FromSoftware Soulslikes, praising its polish, responsive feel, and distinctive identity despite clear inspiration from Bloodborne, Sekiro, and Dark Souls.Combat is often described as satisfying and rewarding once its timing clicks. Perfect guards, blocking, dodging, weapon skills, Legion Arms, and build options give players several tools to approach fights.The blade-and-handle weapon assembly system is a standout feature for many players, letting them combine weapon damage and movesets to suit different builds and playstyles.The dark Pinocchio retelling, Belle Époque-inspired city of Krat, striking art direction, and haunting atmosphere receive frequent praise. Many players also find the more straightforward story and character arcs engaging or emotionally affecting.The soundtrack is a major highlight, especially the collectible records played at Hotel Krat. Players often single out the music and hub details as memorable parts of the experience.Boss encounters and the Overture DLC are widely celebrated for their memorable designs, challenging fights, added story, and expanded content. Many reviewers recommend the DLC, though some find it exceptionally difficult.Difficulty options, summons, and quality-of-life features make the game more approachable than many Soulslikes for some players, including newcomers and those who want to focus on the story.Negative Points
A recurring criticism is that perfect-guard timing is very demanding, while enemy attacks can have long delays, sudden acceleration, tracking, or unclear tells. Some players feel the combat pushes them toward parrying and makes dodging less dependable.Difficulty and boss balance divide players. Some encounters—especially later bosses, multi-enemy fights, and parts of the DLC—are described as frustrating or overtuned, while others feel the challenge is fair and rewarding.Ambushes, traps, ledge hazards, cramped boss arenas, and occasional long routes back to encounters can make progression feel irritating or time-consuming.The linear structure and limited sense of exploration disappoint players seeking interconnected worlds, secrets, or the freedom of a more open Soulslike. Some also find enemy types, areas, or late-game sections repetitive.A smaller but notable group reports technical problems such as stuttering, frame-rate drops, crashes, or awkward camera and collision behavior. Some reviewers also criticize controls, hitboxes, or animations as clunky.Some players find the game short for its price, dislike achievement requirements involving New Game Plus or missable choices, or feel that certain upgrade and customization systems are less useful than they first appear.Several reviewers object to the developer's reported support for generative AI or alleged use of AI assets, which affected their willingness to recommend the game despite enjoying it.Mixed Points
Combat is a major strength for players who enjoy precise guarding and learning attack patterns, but the tight timing, delayed attacks, and less reliable dodge can feel restrictive or frustrating to others.The difficulty is often praised as challenging and satisfying, yet some players report sharp late-game or DLC spikes, uneven boss tuning, and encounters they consider unfair. Difficulty options and summons help, but do not resolve every complaint.The focused, linear progression keeps the story moving and makes navigation manageable, but players who value exploration and interconnected maps often find the world too corridor-like or lacking in secrets.The Pinocchio-inspired story and lore are frequently called distinctive and emotional, while some reviewers find the plot predictable, the dialogue awkward, or the narrative less compelling than the atmosphere and combat.Weapon assembly offers substantial experimentation, though some players settle on a preferred weapon quickly, favor special weapons, or feel that limited upgrade materials make changing builds less practical.The DLC is often regarded as an exceptional extension of the story and gameplay, but its high difficulty and, for some, its length or boss design reduce its appeal.Common Themes
Players consistently compare the game with FromSoftware titles, particularly Bloodborne and Sekiro, while debating whether it is a faithful imitation or a Soulslike with its own identity.Precision-based combat is central to the discussion: reviewers frequently mention perfect guards, parrying, enemy attack timing, and the satisfaction—or frustration—of learning boss patterns.Krat's gothic Belle Époque setting, visual design, atmosphere, and music are among the most consistently praised aspects.The dark reinterpretation of Pinocchio, its more accessible storytelling, and choices around truth and lies make the narrative stand out for many players.The reviews are strongly positive overall, but recommendations often come with a caveat about demanding combat, difficulty spikes, or limited exploration.Updated 11/18/2026, 12:03:02 AM UTC