While Top Spin 2K25 receives widespread praise for its realistic and engaging gameplay, returning fans and new players alike express disappointment in its limited roster, online dependencies, and graphical shortcomings. Issues with server reliability exacerbate frustrations around the always-online model, overshadowing the game's successes on the court. Despite these limitations, the foundation of the gameplay and the nostalgia for the franchise keep the community hopeful for improvements and additions post-launch.
Positive Points
Gameplay is highly praised for being fluid, realistic, and the best among tennis games, providing an engaging and satisfying experience.Animations and movement on-court are highlighted as standout features, contributing to immersive gameplay.Stadium designs and environmental details are well-received for adding to the game's realism and visual appeal.Some players appreciate the game's soundtrack and the effort to include real equipment and apparel brands.Several users mention smooth performance without significant bugs or glitches on their systems.The inclusion of a career mode is generally seen as positive, offering a progression system and long-term engagement for players.Online matches and competitive modes are enjoyable for those seeking challenging gameplay against others.Many users express nostalgia and appreciation for the return of the Top Spin franchise.Negative Points
A significant number of reviewers criticize the limited player roster and the omission of notable tennis stars, leading to a less authentic tennis experience.The game's reliance on an always-online model for various modes, including career mode, is a major complaint, particularly when server issues arise.Graphical quality, especially in terms of character models and animations, is noted to be lacking or inconsistent by several reviewers.Players report issues with game balance, specifically mentioning that certain characters or playstyles feel overpowered in online matches.The inclusion of microtransactions and a progression system perceived as grindy or pushing players toward additional purchases is unpopular.Several users report technical issues ranging from crashes and bugs to poor optimization and performance on certain systems or devices.Lack of offline play options and restrictions on content access when servers are unavailable frustrates many players.Some users express disappointment with career mode's depth and mechanics, finding it repetitive or underdeveloped.Mixed Points
The similarity to Top Spin 4 in terms of gameplay mechanics is both praised as a continuation of a beloved formula and criticized for a lack of innovation.While the game's visuals and overall presentation are commended by some, others view them as outdated or not meeting current standards.Common Themes
There's a consensus that the core gameplay and tennis mechanics are highly enjoyable and a strong point of the game.Criticism of the always-online requirement, especially for single-player modes, is common across reviews.The need for more player characters, better balancing in online matches, and graphical improvements are frequently mentioned areas for enhancement.Updated 7/3/2024, 5:11:29 PM UTC
