Very Positive(84%)
Emotional story
Joel-Ellie bond
Atmospheric world
Stealth survival
PC performance
Linear gameplay
Remake value
Gameplay repetition
PC crashes
Repetitive encounters
Short campaign
Dated mechanics
Sentiment is overwhelmingly enthusiastic about Joel and Ellie’s emotional story, immersive world and presentation, and tense survival gameplay. The main reservation is crashes and inconsistent PC performance; opinions are also divided on gameplay repetition, campaign length, and remake value.
Positive Points
The story is the standout for most reviewers: Joel and Ellie’s journey is emotionally powerful, gripping, and memorable, with character writing and performances that make their relationship feel genuine.Players praise the detailed post-apocalyptic world, expressive character animations, beautiful environments, cinematic presentation, and atmospheric sound design and soundtrack.Stealth and survival gameplay create tense encounters: limited ammunition and supplies encourage scavenging, careful planning, and choosing whether to sneak, fight, or evade enemies.Many consider it an all-time great story-driven game and recommend it especially to players who enjoy character-focused single-player adventures. The included Left Behind DLC is also a highlight for some.Negative Points
The PC version remains unreliable for a significant number of players, with crashes, freezes, stuttering, shader or graphics problems, and inconsistent performance; some report being unable to progress or finish.Some players find combat and stealth encounters repetitive, enemy AI inconsistent, and puzzles or traversal tasks simple and overused. The mechanics can also feel dated or awkward, especially with certain controls.The campaign feels short to some reviewers, and several think the remake’s price is hard to justify—particularly for returning players who see limited gameplay changes or miss the original multiplayer.A smaller group finds the story slow, predictable, or less compelling than its reputation suggests, and some dislike the game’s linear structure or heavy emotional tone.Mixed Points
The gameplay is satisfying and tense for many, but others say its repeated stealth-combat-puzzle loop becomes stale or takes a back seat to the cinematic story.PC performance varies widely: some report smooth play on their hardware, while others encounter severe technical problems even on capable systems.The remake’s visual and animation improvements are widely appreciated, but opinions differ on whether they meaningfully justify buying the game again at full price.The focused, linear pacing helps keep the narrative moving for some players, while others wish for more exploration, choice, or time with supporting characters.Common Themes
Joel and Ellie’s evolving bond is repeatedly described as the emotional heart of the game.Storytelling, character performances, and the atmosphere are praised far more consistently than any single gameplay feature.Players value the combination of stealth, combat, and scarce resources, though opinions differ on how engaging the gameplay remains over the full campaign.The PC port is the most common caveat: technical experiences range from smooth to crash-prone, making performance an important consideration for prospective buyers.Updated 11/20/2026, 12:02:39 AM UTC