Players appreciate the game's innovative control scheme using mobile phones, its approachable take on Gloomhaven-like mechanics, and the fact that it only requires one copy for multiple players. The art and character designs are often highlighted as charming, and the strategic co-op gameplay is a hit with groups. However, the use of phones as controllers can be divisive, with some players finding it cumbersome. Technical issues like disconnections and simplistic storytelling also draw criticism. Overall, Sunderfolk is seen as a refreshing and fun game, especially for group play.