The general sentiment surrounding the Tomb Raider I-III Remastered collection is overwhelmingly positive, particularly for fans who enjoyed the original games. Players emphasize nostalgia and the thrill of replaying these classics with better visuals. However, issues with modern controls and some lingering technical bugs are common criticisms, which could affect newcomers or those expecting a more modernized feel despite the updates. Overall, the collection is celebrated for providing an authentic update on a legacy series while offering new features like achievements that add value.