Overwhelmingly Positive(97%)
Shadow Generations
level design
cutscenes
graphics
gameplay
nostalgia
content length
dialogue changes
Sonic Generations
technical issues
short playtime
dated mechanics
outdated controls
The overwhelming sentiment is positive towards the Shadow Generations segment, which is praised for its excellent gameplay, engaging story, and impressive presentation. However, the Sonic Generations part is viewed less favorably due to its dated mechanics and lack of significant new content, despite its nostalgic value. The game is generally recommended for existing fans of Shadow and Sonic who will appreciate the nostalgia and the new content, but there's criticism of pricing when considering the length of the content offered. As a package, it serves as a celebration of Sonic lore but falls slightly short in offering a fully polished modern experience throughout all parts.
Positive Points
The Shadow Generations part is highly praised for its level design, gameplay, and story, which many consider being superior to the Sonic Generations part. Players find the new abilities and movesets refreshing and engaging.The game is bundled with both Sonic Generations and Shadow Generations, providing good value for Sonic fans and newcomers alike.Players appreciate the nostalgic callback to older games, which are beautifully remastered, especially in Shadow Generations.The graphics, music, and cutscenes in the Shadow portion are highly praised for their quality and cinematic feel.Many players find the control and physics of Shadow Generations to be the best in a 3D Sonic game, improving upon previous titles.Negative Points
Sonic Generations is described as having outdated controls and gameplay mechanics, which are not on par with the improvements seen in Shadow Generations.The game has a relatively short playtime, with criticisms directed particularly towards the length of the Shadow Generations content.Some players report technical issues, such as poor optimization, framerate caps, and problems with controller settings, particularly in the Sonic Generations portion.The Sonic Generations narrative and dialogue have been criticized for being underwhelming and poorly executed compared to the Shadow Generations story.Mixed Points
The inclusion of Sonic Generations is valued for nostalgia but critiqued for its lack of significant updates or improvements over the original.While the Shadow Generations segment is enjoyed for its innovation and depth, some players feel it relies heavily on nostalgia and could have offered more original content.The use of Denuvo DRM received varied responses, with some players experiencing issues, while others did not find it to hinder their experience significantly.Common Themes
Nostalgia and modern improvements: Players value the game for its nostalgic callbacks to older Sonic games, yet appreciate the fresh take and improvements brought in with Shadow Generations.Story and character depth: Many reviews highlight the story depth and development of Shadow's character as an emotional and narrative highlight, contrasting with Sonic's comparatively lighter story.Gameplay and mechanics: Shadow Generations is emphasized for its superior gameplay mechanics and controls, offering a more engaging and challenging experience than Sonic Generations.Updated 7/12/2025, 12:02:53 AM UTC
