Very Positive(91%)
graphics
storytelling
gameplay
environment
emotional impact
complex themes
Abby's character
moral challenges
emotional storytelling
story
pacing issues
Abby
performance issues
forced perspective
The sentiment around the game is largely divisive, with most players acknowledging stunning graphics and immersive gameplay. However, the game's story and narrative choices have sparked heated debate, particularly around character perspectives and key events, such as Joel's death. While the themes of revenge and forgiveness resonate deeply with some, others find the storytelling forced or emotionally punishing. Despite the criticism, many still herald it as a masterpiece in certain aspects of game design.
Positive Points
The game's graphics, animation, and technical execution are frequently praised, with players noting they are stunning and help enhance the immersive experience.Many players speak highly of the storytelling, describing it as bold, emotional, and impactful, with complex character development and a narrative that dives into deep themes of revenge, loss, and forgiveness.The gameplay mechanics such as combat, stealth, and exploration are often highlighted as excellent and satisfying.The environmental design and level of detail throughout the game world receive consistent praise, contributing to a rich and engaging atmosphere.Negative Points
Players frequently criticize the storyline, often pointing out its pacing issues and the narrative structure that forces players to switch perspectives, which some found confounding and disrupted the emotional momentum.The game has sparked division due to certain character arcs and major story events (such as Joel's death), which some players feel undermined their connection to the characters.Performance issues on PC versions, such as crashes and glitches, are mentioned, causing frustration among players.Mixed Points
Many players have a love-hate relationship with Abby's character; while some appreciated her development, others intensely disliked being forced to play as her.The game's complex themes and moral challenges are appreciated for depth but are met with criticism for being heavily handed or preachy by some players.Common Themes
The emotional impact of the narrative is noted by many, with players describing a roller coaster of feelings from anger and sadness to empathy and understanding for various characters.Players often debate the game's handling of revenge and its cycle, with discussions about whether the story effectively communicates its intended message.The introduction of diverse character roles and the treatment of LGBTQ themes within the game world is frequently mentioned, with some expressing it enhanced the depth, while others felt it was forced or unnecessary.Updated 8/26/2025, 12:02:07 AM UTC