The gameplay in Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain is widely praised for its freedom and flexibility, offering a superb stealth-action experience. The open world is appreciated for its vastness, but some players note it as lifeless without much engagement. The game's technical performance and visuals remain remarkable even nearly a decade post-release. However, the story is frequently criticized for feeling unfinished and lacking depth, leaving a sense of what could have been, had Kojima's vision been fully realized. The use of cassette tapes for major plot points is both a unique feature and a focus of critique. Overall, the game is a masterclass in gameplay mechanics, though its narrative shortcomings suggest a missed opportunity to cement its legendary status.