Very Positive(92%)
flexible gameplay
graphics
base management
technical performance
cassette tapes
Quiet's portrayal
unfinished story
repetitive missions
lifeless world
The gameplay in Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain is widely praised for its freedom and flexibility, offering a superb stealth-action experience. The open world is appreciated for its vastness, but some players note it as lifeless without much engagement. The game's technical performance and visuals remain remarkable even nearly a decade post-release. However, the story is frequently criticized for feeling unfinished and lacking depth, leaving a sense of what could have been, had Kojima's vision been fully realized. The use of cassette tapes for major plot points is both a unique feature and a focus of critique. Overall, the game is a masterclass in gameplay mechanics, though its narrative shortcomings suggest a missed opportunity to cement its legendary status.
Positive Points
The gameplay is frequently praised for its flexibility and freedom, allowing players to tackle missions in various ways, from stealth to all-out action.The graphics and technical performance are lauded for remaining impressive even years after the game's release.Open world design and mechanics that encourage exploration and experimentation across its vast maps are highly valued by players.Base management and the recruitment system are considered engaging additions that add depth to the gameplay.Negative Points
The story is often criticized as being unfinished or lacking depth, with a narrative that feels incomplete due to production issues.There is significant criticism of repetitive missions, particularly in the latter part of the game, with some players finding the second chapter to be tedious.Some players find the open-world to be empty and lifeless, missing meaningful interactions and content.Mixed Points
The narrative delivery via cassette tapes is seen as a unique feature but also criticized for detracting from traditional storytelling.The character Quiet is discussed both for her gameplay utility and controversy over her design and portrayal.Common Themes
Kojima's influence on the game is frequently discussed, both in terms of being a creative genius and the negative impact of his exit on the game's completion.The game's technical achievements and mechanical polish are consistently noted as high points.Fans of the franchise express a sense of loss or nostalgia for what the game could have been if fully realized as intended.Updated 6/13/2025, 12:02:00 AM UTC