Overall, the sentiment towards Silent Hill f is largely positive with praise for its atmosphere, story, and art direction, which provide a rich horror experience that resonates with players. However, there is significant criticism of the combat system, which many find clunky and detracting from the intended horror elements. The game's unique take on Silent Hill, set in 1960s Japan, is welcomed by some for its fresh perspective, though others feel it diverges too much from the series' roots. While the multiple playthrough requirement adds depth to the narrative, it is often seen as a cumbersome approach. Performance issues are also noted, impacting a seamless gaming experience.