The general sentiment towards Assassin's Creed Shadows is mixed. While the game is often praised for its stunning visuals, open-world design, and engaging combat mechanics, players frequently express frustration with its repetitive content, optimization issues, and lackluster storytelling. The dual-protagonist feature is a divisive aspect, adding variety for some while feeling like an unnecessary complication for others. Overall, players seem to appreciate the game's ambitious setting and scope but are let down by certain execution flaws that prevent it from realizing its full potential.