Very Positive(94%)
Deep progression
QoL improvements
Idle-friendly
Visual polish
No microtransactions
UI design
Sequel content
Early Access
Idle pacing
Repetitive grinding
UI bugs
Steep farming costs
Low drop rates
Reviews are overwhelmingly enthusiastic, especially about deep, long-term progression, quality-of-life improvements, and polished visuals and audio. The relaxed, background-friendly RuneScape-inspired loop is a major draw, though some players find UI issues and rough edges or feel the sequel lacks enough new content. Overall, fans of idle games and the original are excited for its future, while opinions are more divided on grinding and Early Access completeness.
Positive Points
Players broadly praise the sequel as a polished improvement over the original, especially for its cleaner navigation, expanded quality-of-life features, and per-skill equipment loadouts.The game offers extensive, interconnected skills, long-term goals, and satisfying progression that reward planning, experimentation, and completionist play.Its blend of idle progress and optional active management makes it well suited to playing in the background while working or alongside RuneScape and other games.New artwork, clearer visuals, music, and sound effects make the experience feel more immersive and polished than the first game.Many reviewers consider the amount of content and potential playtime excellent value, and appreciate the lack of microtransactions.Negative Points
Some players encounter awkward UI choices, cluttered equipment lists, unclear menus, visual rough edges, or bugs that affect layouts and clickable controls.A few veteran players feel the sequel is too similar to the original, with more complexity and grinding but not enough meaningful new content to justify a separate game.Some progression and balance elements frustrate players, including repetitive mastery requirements, expensive farming upgrades, and low dungeon drop rates for needed items.Ranching is described by some as passive and underdeveloped, while other players note that certain skills and systems do not interact enough.The Early Access build is missing or still developing features, and players mention issues such as placeholder art, absent language options or mobile support, and demo progress not carrying over.Mixed Points
The revised UI and visual presentation are major improvements for many, but others find parts of the interface confusing, rough, or less appealing than the demo layout.The sequel preserves the familiar Melvor and RuneScape-style formula while adding systems and depth; fans enjoy this continuity, but some wanted a more substantial departure from the first game.Early Access already has substantial content and has drawn praise for responsive developers, though reviewers also expect more features, polish, and updates over time.The slow, long-term idle loop is relaxing and rewarding for fans, but players seeking active gameplay or who dislike repetitive grinding may find it boring.Common Themes
Strong enthusiasm from returning Melvor players, many of whom report spending hundreds or thousands of hours in the demo or playtest.A RuneScape-inspired idle experience that can progress in the background and fit alongside work or other games.Long-term skill progression, interconnected systems, planning, and completionist goals are central to the appeal.The sequel is widely seen as a visual and quality-of-life upgrade, while opinions differ on how much it advances the core experience.Players recognize that the game is in Early Access and commonly look forward to continued development.Updated 11/18/2026, 12:01:28 AM UTC