Positive(94%)
turn-based combat
fan service
well-optimized PC port
improved alchemy
nostalgic
graphical quality
recipe discovery
story progression
subpar graphics
slow start
limited language support
The general sentiment towards the game is positive with players appreciating the return to classic turn-based combat, criticizing some graphical elements, and finding the alchemy system better than its predecessor. Nostalgia and fan service are repeatedly praised, making it a favorite among old fans of the series. However, there are some concerns about story progression and recipe discovery that might affect play experience.
Positive Points
The return to traditional turn-based combat is praised by several reviewers.Players appreciate the nostalgic elements and fan service for old fans of the Atelier series, making it appealing to long-time followers.Many players find the PC port well-optimized, with better performance compared to previous titles like Yumia.The alchemy system is generally seen as an improvement over Yumia, with better mechanics and more nostalgia-inducing elements.Graphically it runs smoothly, particularly on strong hardware, even if the textures are not the most advanced.Negative Points
The graphical quality, especially in terms of textures and shadows, is criticized as being subpar compared to modern games.There's a mention of a slow start to the game with extended tutorials that some found boring.Language support is lacking, with only Japanese voices and limited subtitles, making it difficult for non-native English speakers.Mixed Points
Opinions on the level design and graphics are divided; while some appreciate the graphics and instanced maps, others compare them unfavorably to Yumia.The story integration with gameplay progression, particularly around recipe discovery, received mixed feedback.Common Themes
The game is often compared to prior Atelier games, notably Yumia and Atelier Sophie 2.Many reviewers express excitement about the integration of classic elements with modern gameplay features.Updated 9/27/2025, 12:01:06 AM UTC