Very Positive(82%)
atmosphere
Majula
build variety
Bonfire Ascetics
story
level design
combat mechanics
Adaptability
enemy placement
ganking
boss design
Overall, the reviews indicate a mixed reception of Dark Souls 2. While many players appreciate the game's atmosphere and build variety, frustrations frequently arise from its punishing mechanics and clunky combat system. Despite this, the game is often described as unique and underrated, worth a try particularly for those willing to look past its initial challenges.
Positive Points
Dark Souls 2 offers incredible build variety and weapon selections, allowing for unique playstyles through powerstancing and various dual-wielding options.The game is praised for its unforgettable atmosphere and beautiful world design, with Majula being frequently highlighted as a standout hub area.Many players appreciate the game's ambitious approach to mechanics, like Bonfire Ascetics, which allow players to replay areas at higher difficulty without starting a new game.Despite the initial difficulty curve, players find satisfaction in mastering the game, with its challenging mechanics rewarding patience and strategic play.Negative Points
Players commonly criticize the cumbersome and punishing mechanics, particularly the Adaptability stat affecting dodge roll iframes and the lack of invincibility upon fog gate entry.There is significant criticism regarding enemy placement and ganking, which many feel artificially inflate the game's difficulty and can lead to frustrating and unfair deaths.The game's bosses and enemy design often receive negative feedback, with many noting they are either too easy or repetitive, detracting from the game's challenge.Mixed Points
The game's story and progression are considered confusing and not as cohesive as other titles in the series, with lore delivery seen as weaker but still intriguing for committed players.The level design polarizes opinions; while some appreciate its variety and openness, others are frustrated by the linear and sometimes nonsensical area connections.Combat and movement mechanics are divisive, with some players enjoying the deliberate pace and challenge, while others find it too slow or awkward.Common Themes
The game is frequently described as overhated or misunderstood, with many players suggesting that it deserves a second chance beyond initial reputation.Persistence in overcoming initial difficulties is often recommended, as the game has a significant learning curve but rewards practice and adaptation.There is a common appreciation for the risk the game takes with new mechanics, even if they are imperfect, as they add depth and replayability.Updated 9/25/2026, 12:02:30 AM UTC