The general sentiment towards Dark Souls II is quite polarizing. Players are divided between those who appreciate the game for its unique mechanics, expansive build options, and atmospheric elements, and those who struggle with its punishing difficulty, questionable enemy placement, and some of its mechanical changes. The game is not without its charm, offering intriguing lore and storylines, Majula's stunning hub environment, and enjoyable content for those who are open to its differences. Yet, its idiosyncrasies, particularly the Adaptability stat and hollowing mechanic, have prevented it from achieving the same acclaim as its peers in the Souls series. Ultimately, the game is seen as ambitious but flawed, appealing mostly to those who appreciate its experimental nature and can overlook its rougher edges.