Mixed(50%)
classic gameplay
HD graphics
new modes
local co-op
Speed-Up button
new content
features
developer decisions
AI upscaling
dynamic music
bugs
overpriced
technical issues
Overall, the general sentiment towards Plants vs. Zombies Replanted is mixed, with many players feeling disappointment due to the lack of dynamic music and technical issues present in the game. The use of AI upscaling and exclusion of the original developers have further fueled the criticism. However, the nostalgic appeal and some improvements such as HD graphics and new modes provide a redeeming quality for long-time fans. While these features are appreciated, the value proposition is questionable at a higher price, leading to divided opinions on its recommendation.
Positive Points
Many players appreciate the nostalgic value and classic gameplay that remains similar to the original Plants vs. Zombies.The game includes new modes like Cloudy Day and RIP Mode, which offer fresh challenges and extend gameplay.The HD graphics are generally well-received, with many players noting the improved visuals and widescreen support.Features like the Speed-Up button and local co-op mode add value and convenience to the gameplay experience.Negative Points
The game is criticized for using AI upscaling instead of hiring original artists, leading to inconsistent graphics quality.There is significant disappointment over the absence of dynamic music, which players felt was crucial to the original's atmosphere.Bugs and performance issues are frequently mentioned, detracting from the overall experience.Many reviewers feel the game is overpriced at $20, especially given the lack of substantial new content compared to the GOTY edition.Mixed Points
The addition of new content and modes is appreciated, but some players feel they aren't enough to justify the price increase.While the game has added features, such as HD graphics and co-op mode, opinions are divided on whether these changes are meaningful.The controversy over AI use and developer decisions has divided the gaming community, with some defending the game and others criticizing it heavily.Common Themes
Nostalgia plays a significant role in players' enjoyment, as many have fond memories of the original game.Criticism centers around the perceived laziness in using AI for upscaling and the lack of original developer involvement.There is a strong desire among players for patches and updates to address the dynamic music and technical issues.Players are split on whether the new features and improvements are enough to warrant the higher price point.Updated 10/25/2025, 12:01:40 AM UTC