The graphics and visual improvements are frequently praised, creating an immersive Caribbean atmosphere. Naval combat is highlighted as more engaging and challenging, building on what players loved in the original. However, the remake is criticized for removing hidden blade combat and introducing clunky parkour mechanics. New content involving officer missions receives mixed reactions, seen as lower in quality compared to the original story. Despite these critiques, many players commend the game for maintaining the essence of Edward Kenway's journey and delivering a mostly smooth performance. The nostalgia of returning to such a beloved title is a significant positive, though microtransactions and Ubisoft's launcher issues detract from some players' experiences.