Very Positive(89%)
Compelling story
Visual polish
Bonus content
Loyalty discount
Remaster value
Graphics changes
Replay convenience
Ultrawide support
Chapter selection
Minor bugs
Sentiment is overwhelmingly enthusiastic about the game’s story, characters, and refreshed visuals, with many fans also valuing the deleted scenes and noir mode. The most consistent complaint is stretched ultrawide support, alongside missing chapter selection and some minor bugs. Whether the upgrade is worth buying is dependent on how recently players experienced the original and how much they value the extras, while excitement for the sequel is widespread.
Positive Points
Players widely regard the original game’s story, writing, characters, and comic-book world as among Telltale’s best, and many enjoy revisiting it.The remaster’s more vivid colors, polished textures and character animations, and improved facial expressions make the game look refreshed while largely preserving its original style. Some players also praise the remixed audio.Added material is a major draw for returning fans, including playable deleted scenes, noir mode, concept art, behind-the-scenes videos, and interviews.Many reviewers consider the remaster worth buying, particularly for new players and original owners who receive a substantial loyalty discount. Steam Deck performance, Steam Cloud support, and preparation for the sequel are also welcomed.Players express strong affection for the game and excitement about Telltale’s return and the anticipated sequel.Negative Points
Ultrawide and other wide aspect ratios are unsupported; several players report that the image stretches to fill the screen, making it distorted or unplayable on their displays.The removal of chapter selection frustrates players who want to revisit specific sections, change a single choice, or collect missed content without replaying entire episodes.Some players report minor visual and animation bugs, lighting artifacts, or inconsistent frame rates, while others find the PC graphics and quality-of-life options limited.Some returning players see little difference from the original and consider the upgrade unnecessary, especially if they played the game recently.One reviewer wanted a streamer mode to hide a brief topless scene, citing the risk of streaming-platform moderation.Mixed Points
The remaster’s value depends on what players want: new players and fans interested in the added content often recommend it, while recent players of the original may find the changes too modest to justify another purchase.Visual upgrades are appreciated by many, but some players barely notice a difference; others report small graphical or animation issues.The game remains highly replayable for its story, but the lack of chapter selection makes replaying specific scenes or changing individual choices inconvenient.Players welcome the remaster as a way to revisit the series and support Telltale, while some express impatience and concern about the long-awaited sequel.Common Themes
Strong affection for the original story, characters, and world drives much of the enthusiasm for the remaster.Visual polish and added extras—especially deleted scenes and noir mode—are the most frequently praised remaster additions.Ultrawide display support is the clearest recurring technical complaint, particularly because the game may stretch instead of adding black bars.Many players frame the purchase as a chance to replay a favorite and support Telltale while waiting for The Wolf Among Us 2.The value of upgrading is debated: discounts and extras appeal to fans, but the remaster may feel too similar to the original for some recent players.Updated 10/30/2026, 12:03:18 AM UTC
