The combat and gameplay improvements are generally well-received, offering a more fluid experience than the original. However, there is substantial backlash regarding the cut content, such as the removal of a significant number of substories, and the controversial inclusion of Teruyuki Kagawa. There is also criticism regarding character recasting and story retcons that some players believe compromise the original experience. Overall, while new elements like Dark Ties and improved side content are appreciated, the game has sparked extensive discourse within the community.