Mostly Negative(39%)
Franchise upgrades
Playing with friends
Visual presentation
Custom sliders
Franchise mode
Catch meter
Gameplay balance
Price and value
Crashes and freezes
Broken blocking
Server disconnects
Microtransactions
Sentiment is strongly negative overall: players repeatedly report crashes and server disconnects, unreliable blocking, passing, and AI, and aggressive microtransactions, while many consider the annual changes too small to justify full price. Some appreciate Franchise improvements, visual presentation, and playing football with friends, but these positives are often tempered by bugs and inconsistent gameplay that can make the experience enjoyable only when everything works.
Positive Points
Some players find the core football gameplay enjoyable, especially in casual offline play, Franchise mode, or games with friends.Several reviewers appreciate Franchise updates, including revised menus, contract negotiations, team-building options, weather changes, and added presentation details.Players who enjoy hands-on play mention the new catch and throwing meters, defensive options, customizable sliders, and added positions as worthwhile additions when they work as intended.Some reviews praise the graphics, stadium presentation, soundtrack, and improved performance on their particular PC setups.A number of players say the game is more enjoyable on sale, with mods, or for people returning after skipping several Madden releases.Negative Points
Crashes, freezes, infinite loading screens, launch failures, and lost progress are reported across modes, with many PC players also describing lag, controller problems, audio bugs, and poor optimization.Online and server reliability is a major complaint: players report disconnects, desyncs, matchmaking trouble, and being forced online for modes they consider single-player, including Superstar.Gameplay is frequently criticized for unreliable AI and football fundamentals. Offensive linemen often miss assignments or fail to protect the quarterback, while running backs miss open lanes and receivers drop routine or contested catches.Passing, catching, tackling, and difficulty are described as inconsistent or frustrating, with reports of inaccurate throws, unrealistic defensive reactions, unfair difficulty spikes, and animations overriding player input.Many reviewers feel the game changes too little from prior releases and is not worth its full price, describing it as a roster update or recycled game with longstanding problems.Players object to frequent Ultimate Team ads, battle passes, paid progression, and pay-to-win systems, saying monetization intrudes into both online and single-player modes.Superstar and Franchise receive specific criticism for bugs, restrictive or confusing systems, unreliable progression and simulation, and features that do not work consistently.Mixed Points
Franchise is a highlight for some players thanks to its new features and management options, but others find it buggy, cumbersome, shallow, or barely changed from earlier games.The new catch meter and other skill-based controls are praised by some for making play feel more deliberate, while others find them awkward, inconsistent, or frustrating.The game can provide enjoyable football, particularly with friends or in offline modes, but players often say technical failures or erratic gameplay undermine that enjoyment.Visuals, weather, and presentation receive some praise, though many reviewers feel they cannot compensate for weak gameplay, bugs, or a lack of meaningful improvements.Some players consider the game worthwhile after a discount or with mods, while many say the full-price cost is unjustified.Common Themes
Reliability problems dominate the feedback, especially frequent crashes, freezes, loading issues, lost saves, and disconnections on PC and online-connected modes.The most repeated on-field complaints concern offensive line blocking, poor AI decisions, dropped passes, inconsistent throwing, and animations that make outcomes feel arbitrary.Players are divided on the annual changes: some value the Franchise updates and new gameplay systems, while many see a minor refresh that retains old problems.Monetization is a recurring source of frustration, with reviewers objecting to Ultimate Team's prominence, repeated ads, battle passes, and paid player progression.Despite the criticism, football fans still report having fun in Franchise, offline play, or matches with friends, particularly when the game runs properly.Updated 11/16/2026, 12:04:20 AM UTC