The overall sentiment towards NieR: Automata is overwhelmingly positive, with players consistently praising its deep and meaningful story, phenomenal soundtrack, and unique gameplay mechanics. However, there are criticisms about the PC port, with issues such as poor optimization and awkward controls often noted. The game's design choice of multiple endings is appreciated for adding depth, though it also contributes to a sense of repetition in the experience. Despite some criticisms, the rich narrative and thematic exploration make it a memorable experience for many players.