Very Positive(90%)
story
soundtrack
character development
emotional impact
smooth combat
side quests
hacking mini-game
multiple endings
PC port
repetitive gameplay
navigation issues
save system limitations
The story and soundtrack are lauded for their emotional and philosophical depth, making NieR: Automata a memorable experience for many. However, control issues and optimization problems on PC, along with repetitive gameplay elements, have drawn criticism. Despite these flaws, the game's impactful narrative and engaging characters leave a lasting impression, although its design choices may not appeal to everyone.
Positive Points
The game's story is widely praised for its depth, emotional impact, and complex themes involving existentialism and the nature of humanity.The soundtrack is considered exceptional, often described as one of the best in gaming, with many players highlighting its ability to enhance the emotional experience.Gameplay and combat, while occasionally noted as simplistic, are generally appreciated for their smooth and satisfying mechanics.Character development, particularly for the main characters 2B, 9S, and A2, is highlighted as strong and engaging.The game's ability to evoke strong emotional reactions and philosophical contemplation is highly valued by players.Negative Points
Several players criticize the PC port for poor optimization, requiring mods to fix control issues and graphical settings.The repetitive nature of some gameplay elements, particularly the need to replay sections for multiple endings, is seen as a downside.The game's map and navigation system are often described as lacking clarity, making exploration less enjoyable.Some players were disappointed by the difficulty curve, with certain segments being considered unfair or frustrating due to save system limitations.Mixed Points
The side quests received mixed reviews, with some players finding them engaging and others viewing them as tedious and uninspired.The hacking mini-game mechanic for 9S is divisive; some find it an interesting addition, while others find it disrupts the flow of combat.Common Themes
The emotional and philosophical depth of the game's narrative stands out as a repeated theme, with many players noting its lasting impact on them.There is a strong appreciation for the music, with numerous mentions of specific tracks and how the soundtrack enhances the overall experience.Players frequently mention the game's unique storytelling approach, including multiple perspectives and endings, as both a strength and a potential source of confusion.Updated 9/26/2026, 12:02:18 AM UTC