Very Positive(95%)
nostalgia
multiplayer
content variety
graphic improvements
classic gameplay
outdated controls
DLC criticisms
cross-platform issues
technical problems
toxic community
The reviews convey a strong sense of nostalgia and appreciation for the game's depth and content, with many players cherishing it as a timeless classic. However, there are significant criticisms regarding technical issues and cross-platform limitations, particularly on Mac OS. The community is seen as both a strength due to its activity and a challenge due to toxicity and matchmaking issues. Despite these mixed sentiments, the overall feedback remains overwhelmingly positive, with the game's enduring appeal being a major highlight.
Positive Points
The game retains a strong sense of nostalgia for long-time players, bringing back childhood memories and holding up well over time.AoE2 is praised for its extensive content, including historical campaigns, a variety of civilizations, and regular updates that keep the game fresh.The game's definitive edition has improved graphics and a smoother gameplay experience while maintaining the essence of the original.Many players appreciate the strategic depth and engaging gameplay, which involve resource management and tactical decision-making.The game's community and online multiplayer are active, providing opportunities for both casual and competitive play.Negative Points
There are technical issues reported, such as crashes and startup problems particularly on Mac systems.The lack of cross-platform multiplayer, especially between Mac and Windows, frustrates many players.Some players find the multiplay community toxic or face difficulties with smurf accounts and matchmaking.Mixed Points
While many players love the nostalgia and classic feel, some find the controls and certain features outdated compared to modern standards.The introduction of numerous DLCs is a point of contention, with some players feeling they add value and others seeing them as money grabs.Common Themes
Nostalgia and childhood memories are frequently mentioned, highlighting the game's lasting appeal across generations.The game's strategic depth and diversity in content are appreciated, as they offer replayability and a rich gaming experience.Technical issues and cross-platform multiplayer limitations are common concerns among Mac users.The game is considered a classic or timeless maintaining its standing as one of the best RTS games.Updated 6/9/2026, 12:01:10 AM UTC